Hi everyone!
We had a great AIBD Coffee with Bernie, with lots of helpful discussion among the designers who attended! It was great to see you all!
We started by sharing our most amazing coffee cups, which we normally do, and then we all took a poll using different compensation models that AIBD designers might use:
- Per square foot
- According to construction costs
- Hourly cost, plus expenses
- Fixed rates
- Barter
Per square foot won the poll with 42% of those who voted!
Next, we got into our questions and discussion about what designers choose to use for their compensation model. It was an educational discussion participated by everyone!
Question 1: What are the advantages and disadvantages of charging by square foot versus charging by the hour?
Here’s some of what the AIBD designers conveyed:
Pricing strategies such as charging by square footage versus charging by the hour are frequently debated, with each approach offering distinct advantages and challenges. Charging by square foot is one of the most common methods, especially for residential and light commercial projects. This pricing model offers clients a straightforward way to understand costs in relation to the size of their project. For designers, it allows for the potential to earn more on larger projects and establishes a clear connection between the design effort and the physical space being created. For example, a designer might charge anywhere from $2 to $12 per square foot, depending on the complexity, location, and type of building.
Charging by the square foot can also have drawbacks, particularly when it comes to estimating the project’s total size during the early design stages. Designers mentioned scope creep, that when a project’s size and scope increase beyond the initial estimate, it can cause the final cost to spiral and create some tension between the client and the designer. Also, not all square footage carries the same value. For example, designing a small simple starter home versus designing a large complicated custom home can result in very different end values, even if both buildings have similar square footage. Large custom homes for clients would likely generate more revenue from their space and justify a higher per-square-foot charge compared to a production home. This makes a flat, uniform rate per square foot across all clients less practical, especially for these larger projects.
Some designers use a hybrid approach, starting with a fixed rate for initial phases, such as site assessment and conceptual design, then transitioning to a square footage-based price for later stages like design development or construction drawings. This way, clients can get a clear picture of the cost structure from the beginning, while allowing the designer to adjust their fees based on the final size of the project. Certain variables, such as governing authorities or building codes in a specific region, may influence the square foot pricing, particularly for residential projects where requirements can vary significantly by area.
Charging by an hourly cost, plus expenses is particularly effective for whole-house renovations and additions, where the scope is more un-predictable. For complex projects that require significant interaction with clients, where preferences, tastes, or demands may change frequently, charging by the hour could offer greater flexibility. Hourly pricing ensures that every moment spent on the project is compensated, which can protect designers from undervaluing their time, especially when working with demanding clients. Some designers even compare the two pricing models, square footage and hourly, to see how they match up, which can ensure that the designers remain competitive and fair while also securing profitability.
The concept of “value-based pricing” is another important consideration. This method involves setting prices based on the perceived value the project will deliver to the client. For example, a high-traffic commercial building will likely deliver more long-term business value than a similarly sized residential property, and the price per square foot should reflect that value. While this approach is particularly relevant to commercial projects, it is less applicable in residential work where the per-square-foot value tends to be more standardized.
Overall, the best pricing model depends on the type of project, client preferences, and market conditions. Market research and networking with colleagues can help designers gauge their competitiveness. Whether charging by square foot, by the hour, or by using a value-based approach, flexibility and careful planning are key to meeting both client expectations and business objectives.
This discussion was a great example of AIBD designers helping each other!
The second question was: Have you ever had to modify your services to match a client’s budget? Can you share an example without disclosing any fees?
Here’s what everyone discussed:
Ensuring a proper payment structure is essential for maintaining both the designer’s financial health and the overall success of a project. One crucial aspect is requiring payment before handing over completed plans to the client. Designers invest significant time, creativity, and resources into developing detailed plans, and withholding the final deliverables until payment is received helps protect them from the risk of non-payment. Many designers have learned the hard way that clients may delay or avoid payment after receiving the plans, leaving them with no leverage. As a result, it’s a standard practice to ensure that clients pay first, either in full or for the current phase, before designers give them the final plans. This protects the designer’s interests while keeping the project moving smoothly.
In addition to holding back the final plans, some designers request a down payment up front before they begin any work. This is another critical safeguard for designers. Requiring a retainer or a deposit of 50% of the total fee ensures the client has a financial stake in the project from the start. This not only secures the designer’s time and prevents them from working on speculative designs, but also filters out less serious clients who may not fully commit to the process. Designers who skip this step can find themselves at the risk of dedicating weeks or months to a project only to have the client back out without compensation. As some designers noted, charging in phases is a common approach. Dividing the work into stages and requiring payment before moving on to the next phase helps maintain cash flow and prevents disputes down the line.
Experience has shown that when clients have financial accountability from the outset, they are more likely to respect timelines, honor agreements, and maintain communication throughout the project. In contrast, clients who push for unlimited changes or demand fee caps without upfront payment often end up consuming far more of the designer’s time than anticipated. Implementing clear payment policies not only protects the designer’s livelihood but also creates a professional and mutually respectful relationship between the designer and client.
This was great advice and input from designers, based on their experience, ups and downs they have experienced with clients, and helped us all to gain more insight about our own processes and any changes we might want to make.
The third question was: What additional services do you offer that impact your costs but provide clients with an appealing reason to choose you?
Here’s what designers shared:
In addition to core architectural services, many building designers offer a range of additional services that not only enhance the client’s experience but also add significant value to the project. These extra services can increase the designer’s costs but often serve as key differentiators in a competitive market. For instance, offering detailed 3D renderings, such as fly-through and fly-around visualizations, allows clients to better visualize their project before construction begins, which can alleviate concerns or uncertainties.
Some designers prepare high-performance or healthy home checklists, which include recommendations for energy efficiency, air quality, and sustainable materials, ensuring that the client’s home is not only aesthetically pleasing but also environmentally conscious. By coordinating with structural engineers or other specialists, designers also help streamline the process for clients who might be overwhelmed by the technical aspects of the build.
Beyond technical support, designers help clients navigate the often-complicated world of permits and homeowners’ association (HOA) or architectural control committee (ACC) submissions. Many building departments require extensive documentation, which can be confusing and time-consuming for clients to manage on their own. By offering to handle these submissions or assist with gathering the required documents, designers demonstrate care and attention to detail, saving their clients time and stress. These services come with extra costs, as they require more administrative work and coordination, but they provide significant peace of mind to clients, making the overall design process smoother and more manageable.
Incorporating thoughtful gestures and client care initiatives can also enhance the client experience. Some designers send personalized gifts, such as photo books of the completed home, or host professional photo shoots as a final touch. These thoughtful acts build lasting relationships and show clients that the designer values their partnership beyond the project itself. Designers who also offer periodic site inspections to ensure that the build is progressing according to plan, or assist in reviewing pay applications, provide an extra layer of oversight that can be crucial for a client who is unfamiliar with construction processes.
All of these value-added services reinforce a designer’s commitment to both the client and the quality of the project, while cultivating trust and long-term loyalty.
These additional services, although they can impact a designer’s costs, create compelling reasons for clients to choose and refer them. It is essential to balance care and professionalism. Meeting the client’s practical needs, while guiding them through complex procedures, and offering them personal touches all contribute to a positive experience that goes beyond delivering a design.
As designers, we do our best to help our clients, keep up on the latest codes and advice, and share our knowledge to help each other along the way.
For more information about education, opportunities for Building Designers, and the AIBD Blog, go to: https://aibd.org/opportunities-for-building-designers/.
Thanks for reading!
Bernie